Attorney Christian A. Straile, LLC
Available 24/7 | Hablo Espanol :

Leaving the Scene of an Accident - Did you know or should you know?

The law on Leaving the Scene of an Accident with injury or death had been interpreted to require that you knew or should have known that an injury occurred. There is a knowledge requirement to LSA with injury or death because they are a criminal traffic offenses that are both a felony.  LSA with property damage is also a crime. The requirement of knew or should have known has been applied to the injury element of the offense even if there is a death. However, the Florida Supreme Court had said in the opinion that led to the standard jury instructions that "knowledge of the accident is an essential element of the offense". State v. Mancuso, 652 So. 2d 370 (Fla. 1995).

Now the Fourth District in Dorsett v. State, has reversed a case in which the defendant was convicted but requested a special jury instruction requiring actual knowledge of an accident before he could be convicted of leaving the scene of an accident with injuries. The Fourth District did this because the Supreme Court stated that "one cannot 'willfully' leave an accident without awareness that an accident has occurred" Id.

The issue is one of splitting hairs, technicalities or as I like to put it constitutional protections. The law in Florida is that once a District Court rules, that is the law of the state until another district conflicts or the Supreme Court addresses the issue. The Fourth District requested that the Supreme Court specifically address the knowledge requirement of the crash itself as distinguished from knowledge or constructive knowledge of the injuries. In other words, the district court ruled actual knowledge of the crash is required but the knowledge requirement of the injuries is still whether a defendant knew or should have known.

If you are reading this and find it confusing, then you know why if you are facing criminal charges you should not go it alone. If you or a loved one has been accused of any criminal or traffic offense, and want to hire a criminal and traffic defense lawyer, then click or call today.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response
Firm Logo Small

Learn How I Can Help You

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Gainesville Office
1031 NW 6th Street
Unit A-2
Gainesville, FL 32601

Toll Free: 877-219-1875
Phone: 352-371-9141
Fax: 352-371-9142
Map & Directions

Mailing Address
PO Box 5355
Gainesville, FL 32627

Toll Free: 877-219-1875
Fax: 352-371-9142

Ocala Office
108 N. Magnolia Avenue
Suite 501
Ocala, FL 34475

Map & Directions

  • Location
    Mailing Address
  • Location
    Gainesville Office
  • Location
    OCALA - By Appointment